How do you make a publication for students great? You let students review the publication before it is final!
Students at Owen Middle School in Swannanoa, NC became professional editors for a day when they took part in reviewing a U.S. Forest Service publication called Natural Inquirer.
The students evaluated an issue called “Standing on the Shoulders of Giants – How well do Big-Leaf Mahogany trees grow in different conditions?”
The big-leaf mahogany can grow upwards of 200 feet tall and is found throughout southern Mexico, Central America, and South America — as far south as Brazil and Bolivia. Mahogany wood is known for its deep reddish color, durability, and beauty. For centuries, it’s been used to make high-value furniture and musical instruments.
Students were asked to highlight areas in the text that they found confusing. Were there words that they did not understand? What did they learn from the publication? Were the charts and figures easy to understand or confusing? They added comments and other observations about the draft publication.
“My students enjoyed being ‘editors for a day’ in the classroom,” said Ashley Henderson, 6th grade math and science teacher at Owen. “They truly respected that someone wanted to hear their thoughts and ideas. Having the ability to say ‘this paragraph makes no sense’ and have someone come along and listen to their thoughts and ideas was something really special for them.”
Looking at the students’ comments, they seemed to take the project seriously.
“I learned that not all articles are boring.”
“The maps were a little hard to read.”
“Pretty please add footnotes, I do not like flipping all the way to the back to get a definition.”
“The most interesting thing I learned was the international organizations and programs like CITES also help animals and plants.”
“I enjoyed the charts.”
“[I learned] that many different trees have different purposes.”
Carl Firley, 6th and 7th grade counselor for Owen Middle School, helped coordinate the review process with Brian Cooke, education specialist with the Natural Inquirer.
“Owen Middle School has a strong presence in environmental projects, so our natural resources science journal is a good supplemental reading material for students,” said Cooke.
The Natural Inquirer program produces a variety of science education materials for Pre-K through 12th grade. Natural Inquirer materials are produced by the U.S. Forest Service, the Cradle of Forestry in America Interpretive Association, and other cooperators and partners.
For more information, email Patty Matteson at email@example.com.